Deemed university: Supreme Court asks Centre to put reports online

The Supreme Court on Monday directed the Centre to put on the Internet the recommendations of the Tandon Committee and the task force on the basis of which the government had decided to derecognise 44 deemed universities in the country.

A Bench of Justices Dalveer Bhandari and A K Patnaik also directed that its earlier status quo order would continue till April 13.

The apex court granted two weeks to the aggrieved universities to file their responses on the Centre’s decision to derecognise them.

The Bench agreed to examine the validity of the government’s decision to derecognise the varsities as the institutions claimed that under the statutory rules, it is only the UGC, which has got the power to strip them of their deemed status.

The apex court had earlier restrained the government from derecognising the universities until it decided the issue.

The Union HRD Ministry has already told the Supreme Court that it had given sufficient opportunity to 130 deemed universities to explain their academic performance before deciding to derecognise 44 of them for failing to meet the requisite standards.

Stoutly defending its decision, the Centre, in its additional affidavit, has said its high-powered review committee and task force were more concerned with the academic excellence of these universities, rather than infrastructural facilities.

The government rejected the claims of the aggrieved universities that they were not given any opportunity to present their viewpoints before putting them on the list for de-recognition.

“The review committee constituted by the government invited all 130 institutions deemed to be universities for presentations and face-to-face discussions. However, 126 institutions attended the presentation sessions.

“Further, it is mentioned that the entire presentation session for each such institution ‘deemed to be university’ has been videographed. Elaborate and exhaustive questionnaires seeking all relevant information were also sent to these institutions well in advance.

“The committee analysed the information collected from institutions through the questionnaires and that obtained during the presentations and interaction on behalf of the responding institutions, and finally submitted its report,” the Centre said, referring to the October 2009 report of the review committee directing de-recognition of the 44 varsities.

The HRD Ministry said the universities sought to be de-recognised were being run as family fiefdoms, rather than as institutions of academic excellence, which they claim to be.

“It found that several such institutions had violated the principles and guidelines prescribing excellence in teaching and research or innovations were engaged in thoughtless introduction of unrelated programmes and proliferation of degrees beyond the mandate of the original terms of grant of deemed to be university status,” the affidavit said.


12 thoughts on “Deemed university: Supreme Court asks Centre to put reports online

  1. Pingback: Deemed university: Supreme Court asks Centre to put reports online …

  2. I am a student of J.R.N RVD university. We are very poor.If you derrecognised me I have no path without death. sir I am third year of (mech).please see this students and please do not derecognation this students

  3. I am a student of J.R.N RVD university. We are very poor.If you derrecognised me I have no path without death. sir I am third year of (mech).please see this students and do not derecognation this students

  4. Sir, i m a student of J.R.N. RVD University. I m a final year-final semester in B-tech(civil).agar university dereconige hogaye to meri to life kharab ho jayegi. Pls help me.

  5. I have direct experience with veltech RR &SR technical university for more than 3 years. They have many MOUs with individual named rooms allotted for so called research work. All are with lock and key with dust getting collected inside. They conduct weekend classes to PG courses and each subject they teach 2 hrs/week end day and complete the 42 hr lectures in less than 12 week ends. Students want only without studies,without assignments etc and are happy. They are presently fabricating files for NAAC submission and all faculties are forced to stay till 6/7PM daily. A management Ph.D has been appointed as Vice chancellor for a Technical University due to the observation of Government and remain dummy without powers.
    Any surprise visit by governmnt authorities will prove them straight.

  6. kapil sibal who is self claiming that i m changing the higher education system in india first need to assese the state and central universities first ,most of which are doing worst .go and ask the students of these affected deemad universities i think they would prefer to reenrolled in the same rather than topush them in to state univ. which have very poor standard of education .mr. sibal start ur self praising campaign from the goverment managed institutions then go ahead.

  7. i am a student of one of these universities and i would comment that whether the decision is tit or tat we are going to be adversely affected…
    so i request the apex court to give there decision as soon as possible according to which we can proceed for our future ……

  8. If the goverment derecognise all the 44 deemed universities, what will happen to the students who have already taken admission to those universities? Will the goverment be taking responsibilities of those students to transfer other university.

  9. its so bad ki kapil ibbal doing dis type of thing and sali vo forgner sonia decide kregi ki kya right h

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s